The Key Habit

Lesson 15. Stage 5 of 5: Return

A rule to live by

Every monastery that lasted ran on a written rule, not because monks had more willpower than I did but because they had less faith in it. The rule is what you take with you.

Basis
A practice
Reading time
3 min read
Last updated
Updated

Every monastery that lasted ran on a written rule. When to rise, when to work, when to read, when to sleep. Not because the people inside had more willpower than I did, but because they had less faith in it. A rule decides in advance, so that the tired person at midnight does not have to.

This is the last lesson on the path, and the rule is what you take with you when you leave it.

Why a rule and not a goal#

The research on this is unusually clear. A goal, "I will stop", is a wish with a date on it. A plan written as "if this situation, then I will do that" is followed far more reliably, because when the situation arrives the decision has already been made and the mind does not have to make it under pressure. Psychologists call these implementation intentions. Monks called it the rule. It is the same discovery, made twice, fifteen centuries apart.

Every practice on this path has been one of these. If it is eleven at night, the phone is in the kitchen. If the pull comes, the timer runs for ninety seconds. If I slip, I leave the room first. The rule is simply all of them, written down in one place, short enough to read every morning.

Five lines#

Where the phone sleeps. This is the fence that removes most of the cues, and it goes first.

When screens stop. An hour, and the hour is paper or people or nothing.

What you do at your cue hour. The occupant of the time that used to belong to the loop.

Whom you tell after a slip, and what you do in the hour after. The same-day return, in one line.

What you do every morning. Light, movement, the book, the sentence about the cost. The things that make you someone the habit has less to offer.

Five lines. Read them each morning on the Today page. Revise them once a month, when you are calm, and never at night.

What comes after the path#

Nothing dramatic. That is the point.

The decision was made once, some lessons ago, and it does not need remaking. The count on the Today page will go up, and you will look at it less and less, until one day you notice that you had not thought about any of this for a week, and the noticing itself is the graduation. There is no ceremony for it. There was none for me. There was a morning when I realised the thing that had organised my evenings for years had simply stopped being interesting, and I went and did something else.

You are not giving anything up. You never were. You are putting down something you carried so long you had mistaken it for part of you, and walking on lighter, toward whatever it was you were for. Go and find out what that is.


Sources

  1. 1TraditionThe Rule of Saint Benedict (6th century)The founding document of Western monastic life: fixed hours for rising, work, reading and sleep, decided in advance so that no one had to decide them while tired.
  2. 2StudyGollwitzer, P. M. (1999), Implementation intentions: strong effects of simple plans, American Psychologist, 54(7), 493–503The research finding that plans written as 'if this situation, then I will do that' are followed far more reliably than goals. A rule is a set of them.

Terms used

Cue

Whatever starts the loop: a feeling, a time, a place, a screen. Rarely sexual; usually a state you want to leave.

Slip versus relapse

A slip is one event. A relapse is the decision, usually made in shame afterwards, to stop trying. Keeping them apart is a skill.

Right now